Discussion questions for Haroun and the Sea of Stories
1. Consider the politics of silence as it affects the individuals and
the societies portrayed in
Haroun and the Sea of Stories. Is silence a single
uniform problem, a matter of zipping or
stitching of lips, or is it, like the P2C2E, more
complex? Consider especially the role of the Shadow
Warrior.
2. If Haroun and the Sea of Stories is a clever pastiche of folktale
motifs and elements, what holds
these motifs together? Consider the importance of
the folk tale tradition in the spinning of this
latest postmodern yarn.
3. It has been said by others, earlier this semester, that "image always
comes first." What are the
primary images in Haroun and the Sea of Stories?
To what extent do these images hold the story
together, rendering the characters themselves rather
thin and caricatural?
4. How does Haroun and the Sea of Stories extend or develop the
theme of "family life?" What
family values are at stake here? To what extent
are these connected to a particular cultural context and
to what extent to the family template constructed
in
many folk tales we have read this semester?
How do the Shadow Warrior, Khattam-Shud and the
Chupwalas relate to this "family life"?
5. Word play dominates both Alice's Adventures and Haroun
and the Sea of Stories. How does such
word play destabilize the cultural norms implicit
in the text? How much does it provide a norm of its
own, a zone in which various referential systems
(aquatic and airborne creatures, books or playing cards,
political figures, even the question of interest-bearing
accounts: adventures or explanations) compound,
mix up and complexify? What is, after all,
a caterpillar or a hoopoe?
6. Discuss Haroun and the Sea of Stories and Prisoners of
the Sun each as allegories for a crisis
in national and cultural identity and mission. Drawing
on the cultural conflicts portrayed in each book,
including motifs such as the sad city, the sick
scientists, the switch from a storytelling to an accounting
model, or from a scientific to a magico-religious
approach to reality, explain the nature of the crisis in each
case, and how in each story the crisis appears to
reach a resolution. Is the resolution equally satisfying in each?
Why or why not?
7. In Haroun and the Sea of Stories the terrible question, "What's
the use of stories that aren't
even true?" is asked by four different characters,
each time to negative results. Does the text
provide any answer (s) to this question? Consider
the function of storytelling, the importance/power
of stories, the notion of anti-story, and the cult
of silence in either or both the Valley of K and the
moon Kahani. Make connections, where appropriate,
with the enforcement of silence or the need to
narrate in one folktale.
8. If the story of Haroun follows the outline of a quest story, what
is the object of his quest, and what
purpose is served by his nightshirt with the purple
patches, his theft of the Disconnecting Tool, and
his attraction to Blabbermouth? How are these
three attributes related to each other?
9. Other than silence and speech, Haroun and the Sea of Stories,
in
the tradition of Alice's Adventures,
Prisoner's of the Sun, and Halmoni and
the Picnic lays emphasis on dialogue. How is dialogue
achieved in Haroun? How is it achieved in
one of the other books just mentioned? Consider especially
alternative modes of communication available (telepathy,
dance, etc.), as well as the impossibility of
preventing dialogue (remember that the Wall of Force
is falling apart in Haroun, the Queen and her
court in Alice are discovered to be "just a pack
of cards...", etc.).
10. Consider the conflicts between tradition and modernity played out
in Haroun and the Sea of Stories.
What kinds of power are associated with
either tradition or modernity, and how is that power exercised?
To what group or groups of traditional
texts might Haroun and the Sea of Stories belong? To what group
of modern texts?
(6 points)
Briefly discuss the importance of balance in one folktale and in Haroun
and the Sea of Stories. How is balance achieved? In Haroun,
consider in particular the literal and metaphoric meaning of the juggling
scenes that take place at two crucial points in the book. What statement
does Haroun and the Sea of Stories make on extremes? What statement
does the folktale make?